This episode explores the theme of secret identities through three distinct stories. First, a reporter visits the Trees of Mystery attraction to discover the hydraulic machinery and the person behind the Paul Bunyan statue. Second, John Ronson recounts the case of a man with delusional disorder who convinced a teenager to commit bank robberies while believing he was a CIA agent. Finally, the show features Navy, a high school student who transforms from a shy teenager into a confident mascot, and a mysterious woman in Juarez who murders bus drivers in retaliation for sexual violence.