AI Companies Are Buying and Destroying Used Books
Summary
AI companies like Anthropic are buying used books in bulk to train models, often destroying them after scanning. A bookseller tracked these shipments, revealing they end up in warehouses where books are guillotined for digitization. While this practice is legally defensible as it removes physical copies, it has sparked outrage over the loss of rare titles. The episode explores the ethical and economic dilemmas faced by sellers caught between new revenue and the destruction of cultural artifacts.
Topics discussed
Mystery bulk orders of obscure used books
Introduction to The Journal and host
Sponsor segments: Credit Karma and Indeed
The used book industry and seller reactions
Booksellers compare notes on buyer patterns
A bookseller decides to track the shipments
Tracking results: warehouses and paper recycling
Sponsor segments: United Airlines and Gatorade
Anthropic lawsuit and Project Panama revealed
How AI companies scan and destroy books
Legal paradox: destruction makes it legal
Public backlash and comparison to publisher waste
Booksellers' moral dilemma and economic reality
Long-term risks to the used book industry
The unique experience of physical books
Outro and sponsor segments: Smartly and Amex
Listen ad-free on Castria